Important disclaimer; my iPhonetography is unusually bad here because some of the spotlights in our kitchen have blown - I was also trying to take pictures with the hand that wasn't covered in cheese!
We had a Clue party at our house yesterday (if you have not seen this movie, watch it NOW!) which not only necessitated dressing as our favourite fictional detectives but also prompted the idea of tying in as much of our food as possible with the characters. My housemate suggested adding some (Colonel) Mustard to the mac & cheese I was already planning to make and thus this recipe was born! It's a mishmash of recipes from my flatmate's mom/Nigella/Delia/my pastor/me, so about par for the course with my cooking, really!
These proportions make for a fairly balanced flavour - if you'd like it to be more cheesy/mustardy, then adjust accordingly!
Ingredients:
500g (17 1/2 ounces) macaroni
Half an onion
250g (9 ounces) extra mature cheddar cheese
3/4 cup of butter
3/4 cup of flour
About 3 cups full fat milk (judgement call)
Pepper
2 slices of bread
2 British teaspoons/1 American tablespoon wholegrain mustard
1 clove garlic OR equivalent amount of garlic paste
Method:
1. If you can multitask, set your macaroni cooking while you start to make the sauce. Add some oil to the water and ensure that you stir often - macaroni loves to stick together. You can easily make the macaroni when the sauce is done if you're not a fan of trying to stir two pans at once!
2. Chop the onion and garlic (if using a clove) and fry in a little of the butter until soft. Reduce the heat to the lowest setting and add the remaining butter - stirring until it melts.
3. Add the flour by increments until a thick dough is formed. If you are using garlic paste, add it at this point.
4. Continue to stir on a low heat for 3 or 4 minutes to cook the flour - otherwise your sauce will simply taste of flour (I've done this - don't try it!). If you've not made a roux (the flour/butter mix) before - DON'T PANIC! It will try to stick to the pan and do all sorts of alarming things - just keep stirring and if it does look as though it's going to burn, add a small bit of milk to thin it.
Now is the time to preheat the oven - 200°C/390°F.
5. Add 1 cup of milk and stir until the consistency is even. Add the mustard, and much pepper as you would like. If the sauce is quite fluid at this point, just stir a while until it thickens. If it stays fluid, add some more flour and a bit of butter.
6. Add another cup of milk and whisk until there are no lumps (aside from the onion of course). Allow the sauce to cook, stirring occasionally, while you grate your cheese (hold back a handful of cheese for the topping). Add this bit by bit and stir until it melts into the sauce. By the time you have finished, the sauce should have thickened. Add milk until you are happy with the consistency (therein lies the judgement call) and take the pan off the heat.
7. Place the cooked macaroni in the dish you are planning to use and pour the sauce over the top. Cover with foil and place in the oven for 10 minutes.
8. Take 2 slices of ordinary bread/any bread you like/crackers even and roll between your hands to make breadcrumbs (I really don't understand why people buy premade breadcrumbs). Mix these with the cheese to make the topping. Add this to the dish after 10 minutes and cook at the bottom of the oven for 5 minutes/until the cheese has melted and the breadcrumbs are crispy.
9. Watch family/friends devour it. I was expecting leftovers and got none! Serves 5/6 - adjust quantities to make more/less.


